Joost Koomen, Secretary General of the European Council of Shopping Places (ECSP). Credit: ECSP
Cover Story | Feature

Global Tax Deal Is Not Enough

“Research by CNCC in 2019 showed that France applied 90 different taxes on brick-and-mortal retail, while e-tailers, which represented about 10% of the total market at the time, paid virtually no taxes at all.”

European Council of Shopping Places Column by Joost Koomen

Recent months have finally seen shops, bars, and restaurants gradually re-opening. The latest footfall and turnover numbers from across Europe, though not yet at 2019 levels, are positive and encouraging, providing some much-needed relief. However, the pandemic’s financial impact as well as the risks posed by new virus variants still loom on the horizon.

While we still need to digest and assess the full financial impact of the pandemic, Covid-19 has undeniably accelerated existing trends in the retail sphere. For years, online shopping had, of course, been on the rise, making retail business models increasingly omnichannel. But the pandemic has led to its definitive breakthrough, also reaching countries and communities where penetration had previously been more limited.

A growing concern has been the lack of a level-playing field between brick-and-mortar and pure online retail, in particular, with regard to taxation. Research by CNCC (Conseil National des Centres Commerciaux), the French National Council of Shopping Places and a member of ECSP in 2019, showed that France applied 90 different taxes on brick-and-mortal retail, while e-tailers, which represented about 10% of the total market at the time, paid virtually no taxes at all. That is a staggering differential that is even harder to justify in the current marketplace.

The taxation of digital companies has been high on the international political agenda for several years. However, agreement between countries has been hard to find at both the global and EU levels. In the meantime, several European countries have introduced digital levies. Fast-forward to 2021 and the pendulum may have changed for 130 countries, many of which are in need of revenue to cover the costs of Covid-19, as a new OECD tax deal was endorsed on July 1, 2021. The deal introduces a minimum global corporate income tax rate of at least 15%. It also enables the shifting of a part of taxing rights to the country in which a sale has taken place instead of the country of residence of the company (to combat the “offshoring” of revenues to tax havens).

This deal is a top priority for the EU, and a proposal to convert the OECD agreement to an EU digital tax is expected later this year. However, it would be a mistake to reduce the level playing field discussion to corporate taxation. Other taxes should be looked at, too. More importantly, in order to find fair solutions, EU policy-makers must also consider other aspects, such as environmental impact, operating conditions, social policy, as well as the potential impact on urban planning and mobility.

A review should not also serve as a binary choice between offline and online retail. Its more complex than that as many traditional retailers are shifting their operations online following the pandemic, to complement their existing stores. As retail becomes more diverse and omnichannel, boundaries between the two are blurring fast. The retail property sector is aware of that and has already begun adapting where it makes sense to do so. The increase of mixed-use projects is a case in point. Nevertheless, to safeguard the future of retail, consumer choice, and the shopping experience itself, the playing field needs to become more level with regard to who pays what tax, where, and when. Decision-makers have to become equally astute at adapting to the new commercial reality. To that end, our sector shares an equal responsibility in owning our own agenda. We need a clear and unified voice, accompanied by measured arguments and underpinned by strong data. ECSP and its members have already made a start.

Sign up for our ACROSS Newsletter. Subscribe to ACROSS Magazine.

Feature MORE

Delicacies of the finest quality @Chicken Crime Department Düsseldorf

During my stroll through Düsseldorf's streets, a store immediately caught my eye, both delightful and manageable, but as I said, impossible to miss: the Chicken Crime Department at Ackerstrasse 142 in the creative district of Flingern.

European Retail in 2021 and 2022

One crisis follows the next. While retailers faced nationwide lockdowns, restrictions based on testing, vaccination, or recovery, and already disrupted supply chains last year, the war in Ukraine is bringing the issue of “consumer pricing” to the forefront. Additionally, supply chain disruptions and record energy prices are leading to unseen inflation rates in many European countries for several decades.

Special Issue “Latest GRAI”

We present our Online Special "Global Retail Attractiveness Index".

With tradition and craftsmanship towards the future@Giobagnara Venice

In probably the most famous district of Venice, San Marco, a company has managed to expand in recent months and now operates five stores just minutes from each other: Giobagnara. Two of these stores are right next to St. Mark's Church, another is located on St. Mark's Square, not far from Caffè Florian (there is a meeting room on the second floor with a wonderful view of St. Mark's Square); the fourth store can be found beside Harry's Bar.

Out now: New issue “What the Consumer really wants!”

OUT NOW - LATEST ISSUE! +++ WHAT THE CONSUMER REALLY WANTS! - Whenever consumers face uncertainty, their behavior changes. While retailers have learned to be more innovative, guardrails are needed.