With a sales space of around 78,000 sq m, the Shoppi Tivoli in Spreitenbach is the largest shopping center in Switzerland. Image: Shoppi Tivoli
Studies & Reports

Switzerland: Revitalization boom approaching

According to the current "Shopping Centre Market Report Switzerland 2018", the country's malls have an average age of 30. A number of refurbishments are pending. But that alone will not be sufficient for future market success.

The report emphasizes that a global appraisal of the 197 Swiss shopping centers (with more than 5,000 sq m of sales space) is not possible. Their size, location, profile and positioning are too different. They are an average of 30 years old and many of them have never been revitalized or repositioned.

The "Sihlcity" in the south of Zurich
The “Sihlcity” in the south of Zurich celebrated its tenth birthday last year. Image: Sihlcity

The obsolete building structure and the technical systems that need to be replaced will result in a veritable revitalization boom in the near future. However, it will not be enough to just renovate such properties. For it is also about ensuring their future market success.

In the past, such revitalizations were often associated with the creation of more sales space. Ultimately, the high conversion costs and investments also had to pay off and be justified in the form of “more rental income in future”.

However, the retail landscape is now undergoing massive change. And in times of multi-channeling, digitalization and e-commerce, stationary retail outlets are suffering a crisis of identity. Whereas in the past, retailers expanded entirely according to the motto “as much space as possible”, the motto today tends to be “as much space/as many locations as necessary”.

Falling turnover is forcing retailers to make savings in costs, and the highest cost factors for them are rent and personnel. The consequence: reduction in rent, reduction in space, branch closures or in the worst case closing down of the business. According to the market report, around one thousand stores (out of around 5,500 today) in Swiss shopping centers will close in the next five to eight years.

Further increase in turnover at transport hubs

But let us stay in the present. The 197 Swiss shopping centers include the five largest railway stations and the Airport Shopping in Zurich/Kloten. The total space of the 191 centers (without the five railway station centers and Zurich Airport) is around 2.8 million sq m. As a comparison: In 2000, there were 110 centers with a total space of 1.38 million sq m. This corresponds to a doubling of space.

The Glattzentrum in Wallisellen
The Glattzentrum in Wallisellen is seen as the most productive mall in the country, with CHF 13,852 per sq m. Image: Glatt

After a decline in turnover of 3% in 2015, Swiss shopping centers also suffered a loss of 1.9% in 2016 and thus performed worse than the overall retail market.

For 62% of all shopping centers, the turnover in 2016 was more than 1% lower than in the previous year. Around a fifth stagnated and merely 17% of all centers were able to increase their turnover by more than 1%.

However, in 2016, the five railway stations with the largest retail spaces (Basel, Berne, Geneva, Lucerne, Zurich) were able to increase their turnover again slightly by 2.8%. This with an increase in space by just under 2%. The space productivity of these transport hubs, which was already high, increased further accordingly.

As stated in its annual report, Zurich Airport was also able to increase commercial revenues in a challenging environment. With a space productivity of more than CHF 16,500 per sq m, it was below that of the Swiss railway stations but substantially above that of the country’s shopping centers. As a comparison: The most productive shopping center is the Glattzentrum in Wallisellen with CHF 13,852 per sq m.

New addition: “Mall of Switzerland”

The market report includes an interview with Bernd Hofer, CEO of Freo Switzerland, and Nikolas Löhr, Director of Retail Marketing at Freo Switzerland. They report on the “Mall of Switzerland” which has around 50,000 sq m of GLA and which opened its doors in November 2017 north of Lucerne.

The two project managers hope that the property will also have an appeal beyond Central Switzerland and will meet the expectations of the visitors with regard to a unique experience and shopping center with a high quality of stay and wellness factor. They also want satisfied tenants who see that their decision to be part of the project from the outset was the right one. The “Mall of Switzerland” has not yet been included in the facts presented in the market report.

In general, the report is also assuming a decline in sales in 2017 too. And with a high probability, the decline will again be higher than that of the overall market. This, although many centers have higher customer frequencies, which results in a lower average purchase. This development will continue in the following years. For it is a fact that the current turnover situation is not a temporary crisis but rather a massive change in the market.

Top 25 Swiss shopping centers according to annual turnover (in CHF million) in 2016

1 Glatt Shopping Center Glattzentrum 601
2 Centre Balexert Geneva 407
3 Shoppi Tivoli Spreitenbach 406
4 Sihlcity Zurich 340
5 Shoppyland Schönbühl 310
6 Seedamm-Center Pfäffikon 228
7 Zugerland Steinhausen 222
8 Emmen Center Emmenbrücke 218
9 Shopping Arena St. Gallen 215
10 Westside Berne-Brünnen 214
11 Marin Centre Marin-Epagnier 207
12 Gäupark Egerkingen 201
13 Centre Commercial de Crissier Crissier 201
14 Centre Manor Chavannes 193
15 Surseepark Shopping Centre Sursee 192
16 Avry-Centre Avry-sur-Mer 190
17 Centre Commercial La Praille Carouge 183
18 Mythen Center Schwyz 178
19 Letzipark Zurich 174
20 Länderpark Shopping Centre Stans 170
21 Metalli Shopping Mall Zug 169
22 Centre Manor Vevey 169
23 Léman Centre Crissier 160
24 Wynecenter Buchs 153
25 Volki-Land Shopping Centre Volketswil 151
Source: GfK Switzerland, 2017 Shopping Centre Market Switzerland

About the market report

The author of the “Shopping Centre Market Report Switzerland 2018” is Marcel Stoffel.
He heads up the office of the Swiss Council of Shopping Centers (SCSC) and with his companystoffelzurich advises companies from the retail and shopping center industry, focusing on strategy development as well as marketing, commercialization and leasing concepts.
The quantitative facts of the market report are based on information in the publications of GfK Switzerland.


Follow @across_magazine on Twitter and @across.magazine.europe on Facebook, sign up for our ACROSS newsletter and subscribe to ACROSS Magazine.


Sign up for our ACROSS Newsletter. Subscribe to ACROSS Magazine.

Studies & Reports MORE

Turkish Market Outlook

It is a solemn fact that in order to understand the current situation of any commercial real estate market around the globe, including Turkey, analysis of the current impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the main dynamics of the industry is required.

GfK study: European retail in 2020 and 2021

Probably almost everyone in Europe would like to see a return to normality, to where we have achieved herd immunity, infection numbers are controlled, and coronavirus-related restrictions are lifted. Whenever we reach that normality, it will still be a new kind of normal. The coronavirus pandemic will permanently change the way we work, live, and consume – and retailers will also have to find their way in the new world after the acute shock of 2020 and 2021.

GRAI treading water – pandemic (still) stops recovery in retail markets

Global Retail Attractiveness Index remains weak in Europe. Poland, Germany and Ireland are new top trio in index. UK the only market to see an increase.

Decentralization and the future of retail in German city centers

As if retailers in German city centers have not had enough to contend with in recent years–primarily driven by growing competition from online retailers–now they are also confronted with even bigger economic problems due to the Corona pandemic and the associated restrictions and closures. A continuous analysis of visitor development by GfK shows what has actually happened since the start of the pandemic, who the losers and even bigger losers of the pandemic are, and what the future holds.

Increased Investor Appetite for Grocery Real Estate

A new report from Union Investment and JLL highlights the growing grocery real estate market, with the share of European grocery real estate investment, as a proportion of total retail real estate investment, reaching 22% in 2020, up from 6% in 2016.

Inspiring survey results

Multi recently published its Pan European Customer Monitor + Covid-19 Survey. For Head of Research Mariam Hussain, the most positively surprising result was that 70% of visitors surveyed indicated that shopping centers are valuable places to spend time in and will continue to be especially once the pandemic is over.