Wolf-Jochen Schulte-Hillen. Credit: WJSH
Opinion | Studies & Reports

Shopping Center Performance Report by Ecostra: Fake News or a Scientifically Recognized Method?

It almost reminds one of the 1993 film “Groundhog Day”. The only difference is that Dr. Will, together with his management consultancy Ecostra, has only employed the recurring, annual use of mathematical calculations since 2011, with the purpose of creating a body of evidence, based on statistical methods, that would allow for a ranking of the best shopping centers in Germany to be drawn up.

By Wolf-Jochen Schulte-Hillen, SHSelection

To put it quite clearly: I consider the claim that it is possible to measure the performance of shopping centers on the basis of the method used by Dr. Will and subsequently list them in a ranking of the best centers in Germany to be simply wrong.

Therefore, the publication of such a work under the title of “Shopping Center Performance Report” is misleading, as it is meant to suggest something to the reader that the method applied by Ecostra cannot provide. It only represents a subjective barometer of the mood of a handful of more or less satisfied tenants.

The real estate industry was irritated by the release of this “annual report” and has reacted to its unqualified conclusions by arguing against it in a vociferous and professionally competent manner.

It is merely a simple tenant survey. One should be able to expect that qualified and professionally experienced reporting carried out by the relevant media outlets on the “Shopping Center Performance Report” ensures that this highly important and perfectly technically comprehensible difference is acknowledged in clear and unambiguous terms. Ultimately, however, journalists can always make reference to the title of Dr. Will’s work.

Consequently, it is both important and necessary for the German Council of Shopping Places to provide even the last doubter with a technically sound expert opinion in order to clearly show that the method used by Ecostra is incapable of establishing a ranking of the “Best Shopping Centers in Germany”. Perhaps the team led by Dr. Will has finally begun to realize that their work belongs to the realm of entertainment and not to the real estate industry.


Download the expert report for free:

English version
German version

Sign up for our ACROSS Newsletter. Subscribe to ACROSS Magazine.

Studies & Reports MORE

An Overview of the Serbian Capital

A number of shopping centers have opened their doors in Belgrade over the past few years. In June 2020, BEO, for which MPC Properties is responsible, opened its doors. Development, Technical Operations, and Innovations Director Jovana Cvetković looks back on a time of particular turbulence – not solely due to reasons relating to the pandemic.

Turkish Market Outlook

It is a solemn fact that in order to understand the current situation of any commercial real estate market around the globe, including Turkey, analysis of the current impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the main dynamics of the industry is required.

GfK study: European retail in 2020 and 2021

Probably almost everyone in Europe would like to see a return to normality, to where we have achieved herd immunity, infection numbers are controlled, and coronavirus-related restrictions are lifted. Whenever we reach that normality, it will still be a new kind of normal. The coronavirus pandemic will permanently change the way we work, live, and consume – and retailers will also have to find their way in the new world after the acute shock of 2020 and 2021.

GRAI treading water – pandemic (still) stops recovery in retail markets

Global Retail Attractiveness Index remains weak in Europe. Poland, Germany and Ireland are new top trio in index. UK the only market to see an increase.

Decentralization and the future of retail in German city centers

As if retailers in German city centers have not had enough to contend with in recent years–primarily driven by growing competition from online retailers–now they are also confronted with even bigger economic problems due to the Corona pandemic and the associated restrictions and closures. A continuous analysis of visitor development by GfK shows what has actually happened since the start of the pandemic, who the losers and even bigger losers of the pandemic are, and what the future holds.

Increased Investor Appetite for Grocery Real Estate

A new report from Union Investment and JLL highlights the growing grocery real estate market, with the share of European grocery real estate investment, as a proportion of total retail real estate investment, reaching 22% in 2020, up from 6% in 2016.